Quantcast
CERN Experiment May Violate NEPA, Destroy Universe Print E-mail
Written by Dave Loos   
Saturday, 29 March 2008

(Sept. 10 update: Scientists turned on the collider this morning. So far so good.)

Sometime this summer, physicists are expected to make their first attempt at recreating the energies and conditions last seen a trillionth of a second after the Big Bang, using the $8 billion Large Hadron Collider, buried deep underground near Geneva at the European Center for Nuclear Research (CERN).

This isn't your normal science experiment. The giant particle accelerator -- 14 years in the making -- has a circumference of 17 miles, which will allow researchers to smash atoms together at very high speeds. Scientists hope this will shed light on the origins of the universe.

Others think the experiment will have the unfortunate side effect of destroying the universe.

There's not much middle ground here, which makes the lawsuit filed last week in U.S. federal court so interesting. The suit, filed in Honolulu, seeks to stop the final phase of construction on the LHC. Walter L. Wagner and Luis Sanchon say CERN has not conducted a proper environmental impact statement as required under NEPA.

Oh, and they also allege that the experiment could open up a black hole that instantly consumes the entire planet, and possibly much more.

The U.S. Energy Department, the Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, the National Science Foundation and CERN as listed as defendants in the lawsuit, which reads, in part, "compression of the two atoms colliding together at nearly light speed will cause an irreversible implosion, forming a miniature version of a giant black hole."

It's not just the possibility of black holes that concern the plaintiffs. MSNBC nicely recaps the other doomsday scenarios raised by Sancho and Wagner. They include:

  • Strangelets: Smashing protons together at high enough energies could create new combinations of quarks, the particles that protons are made of. A nasty combination known as a stable, negatively charged strangelet could theoretically turn everything it touches into strangelets as well.
  • Magnetic monopoles: One theory suggests that high-energy particle collisions might give rise to massive particles that have only one magnetic pole -- only north, or only south, but not the north-south magnetism that dominates nature. Sancho and Wagner worry that such particles could be created in the LHC and start a runaway reaction that converts atoms into other forms of matter.

The thousands of physicists working the project maintain that there is nothing to suggest the LNC is unsafe. CERN officials also wonder, as do we, how a district court in Hawaii has jurisdiction over an intergovernmental organization in Europe?

In any event, CERN plans to hold a public open house on April 6 to discuss concerns about the project. We wish we could be there for the milk and cookies as scientists field questions on the end of existence.

As for the lawsuit, the Justice Department, which is representing DOE, says a scheduling meeting has been scheduled for June 16, about six weeks before the before the first planned LHC experiment.

Comments
Add NewSearch
Quack - Fancy such a great big leap, d   | 75.36.140.xxx | 2008-03-30 04:43:19
Well, what's the use of knowing about the universe, and failing miserably at life?
Human beings are on a path to extinction, by their own doings. Until they wise up, even science isn't going to do much good.
S. - thanks for the answer   | 217.151.131.xxx | 2008-04-07 11:13:59
Thank you for your opinion. It is very rare when you meet ppl who understand that human beings are the main reason for current problems. I think that the clue lies in our way of life which is all based on the idea of consumption. We often produce, sell and buy stuff which we actually do not need. We dig Earth, extract resources, waste energy, dam-age environment and pollute/ We even waste our own health and our lives on things which do not actually give people anything but make them more hungry for new stuff. The world economy is growing; it means that more and more people get into this consumption race. Each year we need more to satisfy our needs. That is why consumption of energy is grow-ing - to satisfy our consumption habits. Just a small fact. Average US citizen spends 700 kWh of electricity each month. Average citizen in a less economically developed country say in Eastern Europe consumes 350 kWh. Even though the citizen from East Europe consumes energy far less efficient than a guy in the US, the figure is still significantly less compared to the US. So maybe we should critically look at our way of life first than try to find solutions that would on one hand fight with energy problems, but on the other hand would justify our passions for endless consumption? We talk about products recycling, but we do not talk about using things for longer period. If u look at our business you will see that business even forces people to buy more, to buy often, to change their stuff as often as they can. That means that business or I would say decision makers are not interested in protecting environment. It is just a good marketing tool or tool that helps them distract us from things which are really necessary for ppl. For these people money are more important than Earth.
Unfortunately for us, we do not think about any alternative for the current way of life. We got used to it. Any alternative ideas we consider as harmful cause any limitation to consumption habits means restriction to some pleasures and comfort and keep on killing our future. In this respect all discussions about technical solutions for global warming are just rending the air.
S.   | 217.151.131.xxx | 2008-04-07 11:14:36
guy in the US, the figure is still significantly less compared to the US. So maybe we should critically look at our way of life first than try to find solutions that would on one hand fight with energy problems, but on the other hand would justify our passions for endless consumption? We talk about products recycling, but we do not talk about using things for longer period. If u look at our business you will see that business even forces people to buy more, to buy often, to change their stuff as often as they can. That means that business or I would say decision makers are not interested in protecting environment. It is just a good marketing tool or tool that helps them distract us from things which are really necessary for ppl. For these people money are more important than Earth.
Unfortunately for us, we do not think about any alternative for the current way of life. We got used to it. Any alternative ideas we consider as harmful cause any limitation to consumption habits means restriction to some pleasures and comfort and keep on killing our future. In this respect all discussions about technical solutions for global warming are just rending the air.
S.   | 217.151.131.xxx | 2008-04-07 11:15:31
restriction to some pleasures and comfort and keep on killing our future. In this respect all discussions about technical solutions for global warming are just rending the air.
Donald Omega - Eww false rumors   | 75.143.198.xxx | 2008-03-30 23:54:08
Wow false rumors kill science once again. The scientists working on the LHC have put together plausible explanations of what is expected to happen. Even if a black hole was created during the events caused by the LHC, it would be so small that it would dissipate almost instantly.

These people aren't dumb. They know what they're doing. This could be a major advance in science. Don't let human ignorance and prejudice belittle science once again.
James - uhh   | 71.196.118.xxx | 2008-03-31 03:00:49
These physicists admit they don't really know what's going to happen.
rofl   | 71.160.192.xxx | 2008-03-31 03:39:26
james... do you know whats going to happen when u get out of bed tomorrow... no. not 100% for sure but you have a pretty good idea.

i believe the point needs no further explanation
Rash   | 83.226.134.xxx | 2008-03-31 06:40:20
Wow, that's not the same thing at all. First of all, I don't believe that laymen speculations regarding absurd scenarios should be taken into account when making up ones mind about this, so this piece of trash "article" should just be ignored. However comparing getting up out of bed, and smashing atoms together is really not the same thing at all.

It just shows your bewildering ignorance and retardation to even compare those two things. So your point is invalid, and yes, "your point needs further explanation". There are no similarities between the two, nor is there one single instance of sense in what you are saying.
Anonymous - Uncertainty   | 141.209.194.xxx | 2008-03-31 07:22:26
"rofl" made a decent point, actually: Nothing is ever 100% certain. No matter how safe these scientists believe the experiment to be, there's no doubt that they are working with massive, potentially dangerous forces. With something this high-powered, there's always the potential for something going terribly wrong, and it needs to be decided whether that risk is worth the benefits of this experiment. Remember, just because you can achieve something, that doesn't mean you necessarily should.
Faces   | 75.166.1.xxx | 2008-03-31 07:34:09
Anonymous has a point, Rash. You simply overlooked the simplicity of rofl's explanation. As 'rofl' so clearly said, nothing is ever truly certain, which was the base of Anonymous' comparison.
Bar_Barian   | 68.144.179.xxx | 2008-03-31 08:54:35
I read a quote from one of the physicists at the end of a similar article. He did in fact say that "on a quantum level, anything is possible. This machine could conjure dragons that will gobble us up. It's just very very unlikely."
Silas - who would you sue?   | 70.24.141.xxx | 2008-03-31 10:46:11
One fundamental question has not been asked here. I know it seems quite ridiculous and I'm sure I'll be told as much, and I will give everyone this "it certainly doesn't create much in the way of debate", but if the experiment proceeds and the end of existence is thrust upon us, who would you sue? Quite irrelevant I agree, and the experiment does require more discussion, but in the end, in the frame of the largest of all issues, there would not be anyone left to point a finger at or seek retribution upon. Myself, I say bring it on, if we learn we excel, if not, we parish and no one will ever know the difference.
Andrew - Not same use   | 71.114.170.xxx | 2008-03-31 05:30:18
A cornerstone facet of physics is the principle of error and statistical uncertainty, and how to weigh and quantify this uncertainty.

As a case in point, this machine may show nothing. None of the things the researchers are looking for are likely events; the LHC performs so many billions of high energy collisions per second that the sensor data needs massive pre-filtering before it can even be analyzed. Colliders can perform trillions of collisions before ever seeing one event that is interesting.

So in this way, noone is sure what will happen. That stranglet could be formed, and while it is extraordinarily unlikely, it is still possible, and thus that uncertainty comes in.

Even if it IS unlikely, concern is valid and we should approach with caution. As a friend of mine said, "The physicists working on the Trinity Project were afraid the bomb might set the atmosphere on fire... fortunately we found out they were perfectly safe."
KD - Get the rest of the story   | 68.210.173.xxx | 2008-03-31 06:54:16
This lawsuit is being filed against Physicists, by Physicists. Don't flatter the American rednecks by even thinking they have the competence to come up with a theory related to the world of particle dynamics. But of course, the nature of Physicists is that they're all out to make a name for themselves. If they have to pull a smelly publicity stunt to do it, they will.
Kelly - don't discriminate   | 76.180.67.xxx | 2008-03-31 08:03:50
Stop with the American bashing, KD. It's overly simplistic, rude, ignorant, and completely irrelevant to the topic at hand.
KD - not America in general   | 68.210.173.xxx | 2008-03-31 18:55:02
I was referring to the redneck populace. Not America as a whole. In other words, don't give idiots more credit than they deserve since this lawsuit has been filed by physicists.

And no, I doubt our tiny little ray gun will have any impact on our time-space fabric. Besides, how would you know you've been sucked into an alternate Universe since your alternate self will already be acclimated to that reality?
Mandi     | 216.70.246.xxx | 2008-03-31 08:34:54
Yeah! I'm with you. I consider the size and strength of that machine against the size and strength of the earth/galaxy/universe. Nah, nothing to worry about. I say LET'S DO IT!
mike - fear mongering makes you famou   | 129.82.68.xxx | 2008-03-31 02:44:39
never mind the fact that cosmic ray particles have been bombarding matter on Earth with at least as high energies as the LHC for BILLIONS OF YEARS the LHC is somehow going to kill us all. that's just fear mongering and you should be ashamed.
anon - i concur   | 68.109.172.xxx | 2008-03-31 02:48:21
i concur with don
Deep Blue   | 83.83.44.xxx | 2008-03-31 04:41:42
From what I gathered, the scientist WANT to create the small black hole as explained by Donald, because then maybe some nice new particle may be explained.

And, people, HONESTLY, with the media and one guy on one side, and a whole team of dedicated scientists on the other, who do you believe? I know who I'd trust.

And seperate from that is a philosophical argument whether or not anything is lost if we all get destroyed. I was gonna make that point but it's not relevant. It's not gonna happen.
Anonymous   | 124.170.226.xxx | 2008-03-31 05:13:02
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,342854,00.html

Quote: Not included among the documents is Wagner's own indictment last month on identity-theft charges tied to an ongoing legal battle over a botanical garden on the Big Island of Hawaii, but you can read about that here.
tellos     | 84.226.104.xxx | 2008-03-31 05:13:14
What is for sure is that I will prepare my camera... I leave quite close to geneva...1h30 ... do you think if I run.. I can keep up with a black hole???
Woss - Chernobyl "Knew" What they w   | 80.195.80.xxx | 2008-03-31 05:31:54
Chernobyl physicists knew what they were doing too!
I doubt it will create blackhole to swallow us but i think more consideration for the environment should be made, and an impact study is easiest enough to complete if they have nothing to hide.

Remember these guys are smashing particles together to see what comes out. They dont know exactly what will spill out and how dangerous it is. A very primitive futuristic experiment.
AttemptingReason   | 140.180.24.xxx | 2008-03-31 05:52:59
Actually, Chernobyl was a disaster waiting to happen even by the safety standards of its time. It had no roof on its containment shelter, its reaction became faster when it got hotter (big no-no), it had very poorly designed control rods, and the technicians running it allegedly were not accurately and thoroughly informed of the intricacies of the system. There was every reason for a knowledgeable person to think that it was a crappy system.

Compare that to the LHC. It's basically just a bigger version of previous supercolliders, so there isn't anything potentially more dangerous about it than the type of particles it will produce. We know that the energies reached in the LHC will be far less than the highest energies reached in nature, even today (look up the "Oh My God" Particle) and that any novel particles produced by it will be excessively short lived, or they would have been observable in nature. The LHC won't be doing anything new to the earth, it will just be doing it where scientists can finally get a good look.
Solar boy - God is a scientist     | 87.5.166.xxx | 2008-03-31 06:23:55
If we annihilate this universe and create a new one then we are GOD! Cool!!
Actino - CERN is in Europe   | 85.241.141.xxx | 2008-03-31 06:36:47
well another proof of the stupidity that americans tend to show off.
CERN is in Europe and it doesn't have to follow or care about NEPA!!
This is so stupid. It's like Bin Laden makes a lawsuit against Bush in any islamic country. Imagine that he wins and Bush is sentenced to life in prison. What would happen?
Nothing.
Except publicity.
That's what these people want. 15 minutes of fame..
Ben - Why American-bashing?   | 63.117.115.xxx | 2008-03-31 10:09:47
I'm American and can't wait to see the results out of the LHC. The same goes doubly for the many American scientists who will be conducting experiments there alongside their European and Asian fellows. Can we not take an incredible international collaboration and find a way to twist it to bash one country, please? Belief that all Americans are the same is as bigoted as any other stereotype, regardless of whether it's in vogue right now.
phil - just so you know...     | 69.126.29.xxx | 2008-04-01 02:12:25
The americans ARE apart of this thing. We were building a super colider in texas ( a few years into it) and stopped to help fund the one with CERN. IIRC there are 14 different countries who are involved with the program. Not all of us americans are like these people and making a statement such as yours is a really bad statement to make.


after saying that I have been looking foward to this for about 5 years now, IF one of us americans actually does stall this from starting, please think before you get angry at "americans"
Shane   | 86.44.202.xxx | 2008-09-05 16:59:06
There are plenty of Americans working at CERN
Ed Mays - God is gonna be mad....   | 76.119.172.xxx | 2008-03-31 06:49:16
Once God finds out about these jokers at CERN there is going to be hell to pay.
soar - But...     | 67.71.100.xxx | 2008-03-31 09:07:24
God isn't real so no one has to worry.
al   | 90.211.150.xxx | 2008-03-31 13:16:23
and even if he were real, I thought he was supposed to be omnipotent and omniscient, so technically he should know about it and have done something about it already.

Or maybe he's talking to Santa, to make sure those naughty scientists dont get any xmas presents this year?!
Just a sign on the road (what   | 77.49.81.xxx | 2008-06-03 17:43:37
You
wish my friend! Deep down wish. But it's not going to happen. Do worry!
Rev 20:15 And whosoever was not found written in the book of life was cast into the lake of fire.
2Pe 3:10 But the day of the Lord will come as a thief in the night; in the which the heavens shall pass away with a great noise, and the elements shall melt with fervent heat, the earth also and the works that are therein shall be burned up. 11 Seeing then that all these things shall be dissolved, what manner of persons ought ye to be in all holy conversation and godliness, 12 Looking for and hasting unto the coming of the day of God, wherein the heavens being on fire shall be dissolved, and the elements shall melt with fervent heat? 13 Nevertheless we, according to his promise, look for new heavens and a new earth, wherein dwelleth righteousness.

In due time (not very very long), everything will be made clear, and then "soar..." you'll know Who's... Real... and you'll have "real" reasons to be "soar"!! Not funny at all!
His love is still there for you! Christ's sacrifice can still save you. The door is still open, but closing. Find out about Jesus Christ in some Protestant Evangellical church. Go and ask questions, doubt, but search! Don't just stand around with your head in the ground.
For your sake, please hurry. Bye! God bless you!!!
michael   | 83.209.20.xxx | 2008-03-31 06:55:38
jeez, I can't believe I am giving a comment to this, even. If there were any real concern by the worlds scientific community, I would expect that something more than a lawsuit in honolulu would be heard. A black hole btw is not likely to form. Try to read up on black holes and what they actually are. It's just as likely as they will create a microscopic star that will burn upp the planet. If we did'nt research what we don't know about, we would still be afraid of fire.
wherewillwhy@gmail.com - imaginet innovation     | 206.75.76.xxx | 2008-03-31 07:44:28
I SAY FIRE IT UP !! STOP BEING PUSSYS
Anonymous   | 87.194.151.xxx | 2008-03-31 08:07:40
The 'N' in NEPA stands for National.. as in the 'Nation' of the United States of America.

Hey, America, Geneva is in Switzerland, not the USA, that means it is not within your national boundaries, that means... f*** off!
phil     | 69.126.29.xxx | 2008-04-01 02:14:18
The americans are apart of this project. I like to tell my government to fuck off as well, but please dont lump us all in with these kind of people
uboat   | 24.14.247.xxx | 2008-03-31 08:48:43
ok so all i have to add, is that fermilab a smaller collider that is in illinois has the physicist at cern worried they will discover these things first, yet no one is filing court cases against this lab, and it is in freaking america, this is just a dumb stunt, i mean if it wasnt safe and didnt have tons upon tons of resaearch done you really think it would be happening in america already? no.
geoff - think about it   | 67.82.73.xxx | 2008-03-31 09:16:22
where exactly is the energy to destroy the world going to come from? The actual tunnel or the materials used? It is a self-limiting system at CERN. Please let us focus on real problems. A valid critique might be the energy used thats it.
Alec - @geoff     | 206.192.68.xxx | 2008-03-31 09:31:02
Finally someone with some sense. Anyone with even undergraduate physics experience can tell you that any "small black holes" would exhaust themselves almost instantaneously. These concerns are brought forward by people -who aren't even in the field of physics.-

No, the scientists are not 100% sure of what kinds of conditions will be created in these scenarios, for the same reason that I can't prove my coffee mug won't suddenly implode upon itself. It's not very likely.
Rage - Stupid   | 192.30.100.xxx | 2008-03-31 10:03:24
"Don't let human ignorance and prejudice belittle science once again."

We can't keep creationists out of the damn school system and you expect people to be reasonable about a 17 mile tunnel designed to smash atoms?
nooneyouknow   | 65.5.204.xxx | 2008-03-31 10:38:35
Are you one of those guys that sound like, smell like and look like an ape?
You shouldn't be insulted since you believe that you are a descendant of one. If anything, the apes might be offended.

There is absolutely no evidence that evolution is pure science. It isn't science, it is pure conjecture without any archaeological proof and without veracity.
nooneyouknow   | 65.5.204.xxx | 2008-03-31 10:27:48
You foolish people! Read the complaint first before you start mouthing off.

This is a legal action to ensure compliance and a delaying action, not a scare tactic as some morons suggest.

This suit seeks only a few primary objectives:
a) A temporary restraining order be issued restraining defendants from operating the LHC or further preparing the LHC for operation for four months;
b) A preliminary injunction enjoining defendants from operating the LHC until after they have completed either a FONSI or EIS, as appropriate, be issued and to last until such time that such FONSI or EIS has been reviewed by plaintiffs or the court and approved for operation;
c) A permanent injunction be issued enjoining defendants from operating the LHC until such time that the LHC can be proven to be reasonably safe within industry standards"

Nothing wrong with that, is there?
Anonymous   | 87.194.151.xxx | 2008-03-31 15:34:11
You mean other than the EPA having no juristiction over the LHC?
Anonymous   | 87.194.151.xxx | 2008-03-31 15:37:07
At a guess, its just america being sore that there is a chance of someone other than america destroying the world by accident.

After all, screwing up the environment, bringing us all to the brink of nuclear war - several times - demolishing faith in human rights processes, demolishing faith in justice, causing fear worldwide, creating an environment of hatred and bigotry around the world. Those are all the monopolies of the US, no europeans better try to be getting in on this 'destroying civilisation' gig!
sujee   | 59.96.26.xxx | 2008-09-11 07:05:54
You are 100% correct . Where has these human rights activist gone these days? Have they gone for holidays in heaven? Poor public are accepting what ever is done to them.
Anonymous - re:   | 59.96.26.xxx | 2008-09-11 07:06:53
You are 100% correct . Where has these human rights activist gone these days? Have they gone for holidays in heaven? Poor public are accepting what ever is done to them.[/quote]
K   | 84.74.175.xxx | 2008-03-31 16:55:59
It's the equivalent of "I don't understand, so you probably better not do that".
Heather     | 216.161.217.xxx | 2008-04-01 10:54:02
Otherwise known as the precautionary principle.
JOJO   | 69.11.32.xxx | 2008-03-31 18:03:36
Hey last time I checked we had problems like global climate change, poverty, oppression, severe depletion of resources, species extinction etc. Unless this experiment is somehow going to solve this I suggest maybe pouring those resources into improving the problems we have. Hasn't science realized by now that the god of 'progress' has lead us to the brink of our own destruction. For people who are so smart they can be incredibly stupid and shortsighted. That's billions of dollars spent on a question that we never need to know to function happily and sustainably in the world. We need to save our God complexes for when we're not neck-deep in our own sh*t.
Martin - Sad   | 81.6.234.xxx | 2008-04-05 07:16:22
It's tough sharing the planet with so many cretins and luddites.
Religion needs to be banned by the way.
graham   | 86.15.240.xxx | 2008-04-06 12:15:24
I am an expert at asking stupid questions, but I am correct in assuming the experiments are trying to recreate the start point of the universe, the starting point for gravity to being created. MORE IMPORTANTLY IF THEY KNOW WHATS GOING TO HAPPEN WHY DO THEY NEED TO DO THE EXPERIMENT
Anonymous - No one knows   | 85.228.131.xxx | 2008-04-13 12:31:14
The don't know. That's why they will do experiments. It is in human nature to be curious. It is also to be afraid of new stuff. I guess you are one of the latter.
Alex Hodson - Mr   | 67.91.218.xxx | 2008-04-06 19:25:40
Who knows, getting sucked into a black hole could be the best thing that ever happened to us.
Jenn Rodenbarey - Planetary birth control   | 71.112.198.xxx | 2008-04-06 20:19:06
The Cure is coming