Paranoid brains at a think thank in Canada are demanding the Canadian government outlaw sending bulk shipments of water to the United States. The thirsty thinkers are worried that the drying West will eventually cause the US to look north for ways to keep their lawns green.
The Canadian government told the Polaris Institute to chill out, since the export of water as a commodity is illegal under NAFTA. But, the group points out that presidential candidates Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton have been talking about making changes to NAFTA once they get into office. It's worth noting that much of this campaign rhetoric has focused on states suffering job losses that have been blamed on the free trade agreement, not on stealing Canada's water.
We suggest that instead of worrying about saving Canada's abundant fresh water resources from export, Canadians spend their energy trying to prevent the export of oil from tar sands. Not only is oil production from tar sands extremely degrading to the environment, it is also water intensive, using at least one barrel of water for ever barrel of oil produced. And since that oil is destined for the US, it's an equally effective way to stop the US from stealing Canada's water.
I live in Guelph, Ontario - 40 min drive from Toronto. Trust me, Canadians need to be 'paranoid' about protecting our water resources. Learn more from here: http://canadians.org/media/council/2008/22-Mar-08.html
While I will admit, if I was from Canada I'd probably be siding with you ladies too. But, considering how there are plenty of other nations with much lower per capita water availability than the US (some Middle Easter countries like Kuwait have virtually no water), I think this is really a non-issue right now. 80% of wester water consumption comes from agriculture, much of it done in the desert. I think there will be a virtual water trade, where water used in Canada to grow produce is shipped to the US, before there is any actual water being diverted, it's just easier that way.
Too bad we can't virtually transfer the food as well and really save us all a whole bunch of work!
What makes you think that Canada is capable of sustaining agriculture at the rate that the US is? Canada doesn't have the climate to grow, say, the oft quoted California salad in January. It's just not possible without greenhouses, and we know they are expensive and energy intensive to run.
Places with no water (Kuwait) generally have something to trade for the technology (desalination, for example) to get the water. Consider the population density of Saudi Arabia anywhere outside of the coastline or where intensive oil production is ongoing; it's going to be similar to that of northern Canada, where the only people who live there are either living traditionally (and at razor thin population densities) or are supported by shipped in food from the productive southern US and Mexico because it turns out that diamond mining and oilsand extraction is worth the effort!
One more; Just because it's not a pressing issue now doesn't mean we shouldn't be watching out for future problems. Proactivity! I don't want to end up being forced to send water south while we dry up ourselves. We can't drink oil or money.
To the author; thanks for telling us what to do, 'cause we're apparently idiots. It's not like there aren't activists/scientists/grassroots people dealing with the oilsands *and* water issues. How about the author worries about one problem at a time as well and we'll see how that works out for you, eh?
Those of us who give a crap know how the oilsands work and that something needs to be done; we also know that water is vastly undervalued by our society and someday we'll see a balancing of the books.
Want to be taken seriously? Start by researching the issue before calling an entire nation paranoid.
I don't see much sense in taking environmental advice from our "friends" south of the border. Their track record speaks for itself. Perhaps if the insatiable demand for oil in the United States was reduced we would never have found ourselves in this situation. Last time I checked it wasnt Canadians who were fighting over the right to exploit the tar sands.
Hate to burst your bubble, Patrick, but the Canadian Frontier Center has enumerated some reasons here: http://www.fcpp.org/main/publication_detail.php?PubID=1365
as to why Canadians will benefit from climate change, one of them being increased agricultural output.
Hating on the US may be fun and easy, but we aren't *making* the Canadian government destroy its environment to harvest oil and diamonds (which btw, are exported to other nations, and presumably purchased by some Canadian citizens too).
Anyway, at least the US has outlawed clubbing baby seals. :P ~"The author"
I'm gonna split this into two parts so that it all shows up.
I can see that the level of professional discourse around here is apparently cheap shots at a controversial topic. Throwing rocks when we live in glass houses, and all that. Emoticons don't make it okay. I thought this place was serious.
Yes, Canada will "benefit" from climate change in some ways. So are you then arguing for climate change? That seems an...unorthodox position coming from a writer for what seems to be a pro-environmental website.
Hating on the US is fun and easy; it's always easy to take shots at the big guy. I'm not here to do that though. I'm here to talk about environmental stuff and get you to tell us why you seem to think that it's okay to call us all paranoid.
we should be hogging ouwater when every 1 else runs out then we can laugh at them then say wel lsell u expensive water thats for selling us expensive gas
I've lived in various parts of Alberta my whole life. I've lived in the Palliser Triangle, where agriculture squeaks by on virtue of irrigation (hey, pumping water out of the ground seems to salinate the soil and makes it unable to support plant life after a while! I guess we'll get that water from the rivers. Oh, except they're already all allocated out. Huh.). I've lived in the foothills and seen the benefit the pine beetle has brought as the winters have become warm enough to not kill them off. I currently live in central Alberta, where a huge fight to prevent a race track/casino/megamall/hotel/entertainment complex from diverting water from our watershed happened because it turns out that communities downstream will be affected. I don't see how a dryer, warmer climate does us here any good at all, and we're (Alberta) a big part of the problem.
Our economy here lives and breathes Oil and Agriculture. I grew up on agriculture and I get paid on oil. Tell me again how you know better than me.
Please, step back and take a look at what you've written. You made no serious attempt to rebut any of my previous points, except for 2 minutes with Google. If you want to be serious though, I'm ready to have mature discourse.
fncv25 The good news, the gold price concessions, more secure transactions!
To pay wow goldtribute to the broad masseswow gold of Warcraft player has beenwow gold on my WebWorld of Warcraft gold site support,wow power leveling I held a gold site offers! Another launch gold coins to buy tickets to send cash Dailian. To buy the rest assured of playing happy!wow power leveling World of Warcraftwow power leveling all types of businesswow power leveling Dailian prices are 9 Fold wow power levelingpackage business for more concessions!
I createwow power leveling a new Web site World of Warcraft gold ofwow power leveling the new service concept,wow power leveling the region off-the-shelf,rs gold hand-built pure gold, so you buy the rest assured that with the peace of mind. You do not have to worry about enough to buy gold after Runescape Goldthe account was closed for fear thatRuneScape Money as long as you need, rolex replicaPlease be assured that links us,replica rolex we will ensure that the first service,Rolex safety first First,Watches Rolex the quality of the first.Rolex Watches I site is China's largest online game virtual item trading platform, World of Warcraft gold, limited edition Feng Qiang! Region-wide value buying clothes, a limited supply! And other equipment, such as consignment Watch Rolexaccount and transaction security services, To provide a variety of virtual goods transactions in a secure environment .24-hour customer
Services, a variety of payment methods, Rolex Watchand convenient transaction security, all goods have a server!
FLV Converter Mac is a powerful FLV Converter for Mac software which can convert FLV video files to all popular video formats and convert FLV to popular audio formats for Mac OS X users. FLV Converter Mac OS X softwrare supports all video popular formats indcluding FLV, MPG, MPEG1, MPEG2, MP4, 3GP, 3G2, MOV, AVI, Mpeg TS/TP (for HD Video), etc. The Mac FLV Converter can also convert FLV to MP3, WAV, OGG, 3GP, AAC and M4A, AC3, APE, etc audio.
Mac DVD Ripper is an all-in-one DVD ripper for Mac OS X software. This Mac DVD Ripper is an excellent DVD Decryption tool for Mac users to rip DVD to various video formats (including MP4, AVI, M4V, MOV, 3GP, MPG, FLV) and audio formats (MP3, M4A, AAC, WAV, OGG, APE, etc.) for playback on iPod touch, iPod classic, iPod nano, iPhone, Apple TV, PSP, PS3, Youtube (web), Creative Zen, iRiver PMP, Archos, all kinds of video cell phones and digital video and audio players. The Mac DVD Ripper is what godgious you need to put your DVD movies on your mobile devices.This Mac DVD Ripper software lets you select DVD subtitle and audio track, choose any DVD chapters/titles you want to convert, trim any DVD chapters/titles, and even merge more than one DVD chapter/title into a single file. Put your DVD movies on almost any mobile devices with this professional Mac DVD Ripper Software! please take a carefully look at the following link:Mac DVD Ripper.and another a greate converter software is vob converter for mac.VOB Converter for Mac is an excellent VOB to Video conversion software for Mac OS users to convert VOB files on Mac to various video formats perfectly and quickly. The Mac VOB converter supports converting VOB to mp4, avi, mov, mpeg-4 etc and also converting to PSP, Apple TV , iPod, iPhone, Archos, video mobile phone, Zune, etc. Aha,please come in the following link:VOB Converter for Mac
DVD burner for Mac provides an easy and fast way to convert popular video formats (including AVI, MPEG, WMV, DivX, XviD, MP4, DV, VOB, ASF, 3GP, NUT, YUV, H.264/AVC, M4V files to DVD. The DVD Burner Mac could also burn DVD movie onto DVD disk that playable on portable or home DVD player and burn DVD folder or ISO files. No other Mac DVD burner can provide so many formats. AVI to DVD for Mac, a profeesional but easy-to-use DVD burn software for Mac users, can convert AVI to DVD format on Mac OS X perfectly and quickly. The AVI to DVD Mac not only supports converting AVI to DVD Mac but also supports other popular formats to DVD on Mac, such as MPA, ASF, DIF, H261, YUV, NUT and so on.
[url=http://www. divxtodvdconverterma
c.com/]DivX to DVD Converter for Mac[/url]can not only convert DivX to DVD Mac, but also support convert AVI to DVD, 3GP to DVD, MP4 to DVD, FLV to DVD, MPEG to DVD, WMV to DVD, etc.
MPG Converter for Mac, MPG to AVI for Mac, MPG to MOV for Mac, MPG to MP4 for Mac, MPG to 3GP for Mac, MPG to FLV for Mac, MPG to DVD for Mac, MPG to iPod for Mac, MPG to iPhone for Mac, MPG to Apple TV for Mac,
[url=http://www. appletvconverterform
ac.com]Apple TV Converter for Mac[/url],
[url=http://www. appletvconverterform
ac.com/dvd-to-apple-tv-for-mac.html]DVD to Apple TV for Mac[/url],
[url=http://www. appletvconverterform
ac.com/flv-to-apple-tv-for-mac.html]FLV to Apple TV for Mac[/url],
[url=http://www. appletvconverterform
ac.com/avi-to-apple-tv-for-mac.html]AVI to Apple TV for Mac[/url],
[url=http://www. appletvconverterform
ac.com/wmv-to-apple-tv-for-mac.html]WMV to Apple TV for Mac[/url],
[url=http://www. appletvconverterform
ac.com/vob-to-apple-tv-for-mac.html]VOB to Apple TV for Mac[/url],
[url=http://www. appletvconverterform
ac.com/mpeg-to-apple-tv-for-mac.html]MPEG to Apple TV for Mac[/url],
[url=http://www. appletvconverterform
ac.com/dat-to-apple-tv-for-mac.html]DAT to Apple TV for Mac[/url],
[url=http://www. appletvconverterform
ac.com/divx-to-apple-tv-for-mac.html]DivX to Apple TV for Mac[/url]
Yeah, OK, we can be the change that we want to see in the world. But unless powerful people in powerful positions want to be that change as well, nothing's going to change.
So now, finally, there's a place where you can go for news and analysis of politics from an environmental perspective.