Quantcast
Skeptics Stretch Definition of "Scientist" 31,000 Times Print E-mail
Written by Dave Loos   
Monday, 19 May 2008

In keeping with the amount of virtual ink this item deserves, we're going to try and keep this short. The Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine held a press conference this morning to announce that 31,000 "scientists" have signed a petition rejecting claims of human-caused global warming.

According to OISM officials, the purpose of the Petition Project is to demonstrate that "the claim of 'settled science' and an overwhelming 'consensus' in favor of the hypothesis of human-caused global warming and consequent climate damage is wrong."

So what does it take to be included among the 31,000 "experts" on the petition? Well, according to the OISM criteria, any undergraduate science degree will do just fine. Bet you never thought that BS you earned 20 years ago made you a qualified climatologist. Congratulations!

OISM also wants to let you know that 9,021 of the signers hold PhDs. They don't specify what the doctorates are in, but they repeat that figure quite a bit, as if it means something. Since the group was nice enough to list all 31,000 signers, including the dead people, let's take a look at the qualifications of three randomly-selected "climate experts."

  • W. Kline Bolton, M.D. is a professor of medicine and Nephrology Division Chief at the University of Virginia. Nephrology deals with the study of the function and diseases of the kidney.
  • Zhonggang Zeng is one of the 9,000 with a PhD. He is a professor of mathematics at Northeastern Illinois University. His most recent publication is entitled "Computing multiple roots of inexact polynomials."
  • Hub Hougland is a dentist in Muncie, Indiana. He was inducted into the Indiana Basketball Hall of Fame last year.
Comments
Add NewSearch
Earth & Economy - No "Convincing" vs "Substan     | 69.181.174.xxx | 2008-05-19 18:40:49
I enjoyed the use of the adjectives "convincing" and "substantial" in this petition. Both allude to varying degrees of uncertainty. The petition couldn't simply state, "There is no scientific evidence that human release of carbon dioxide..." (without including the adjective convincing) because that would be a flat out lie, so the word "convincing" is loaded because obviously the evidence is not convincing or else this issue would not continue to be debated. I would have to agree it is not convincing by the mere fact there are still skeptics, but I also wouldn't blame the lack of scientific evidence for their skepticism. I think it is safe to assume their are other factors at play. So when it comes to the "substantial" amount of scientific evidence that increases in C02 benefit plant and animal environments, I would say no duh if we are talking about photosynthesis which is required by plants to live—plants that feed animals. But really, I would love to see someone suck on a tailpipe from their vehicle or even breathe in exhaust in close quarters and tell me that is "substantial" CO2 for a human animal in their natural environment...in this case a garage (which isn't natural by any means). So, between the wording of the petition or the generalized degree credentials for these "educated" signees, I don't think much has been convincingly and substantially clarified. Humans are harming the planet, period. No debate. If you don't believe in doing good for the planet then maybe you should invest in space exploration (or take a hit from a tailpipe) and spare the rest who care from this noise. Let's say this petition is correct, then what next...do nothing because we aren't responsible?
wholesale jewelry - wholesale jewelry     | 222.131.26.xxx | 2008-10-12 22:56:18
wholesale jewelry
handmade jewelry
handcrafted jewelry
wholesale handmade jewelry
wholesale pearl
wholesale turquoise jewelry
wholesale coral jewelry
wholesale shell jewelry
wholesale handcrafted jewelry
wholesale gemstone jewelry
fashion jewelry
Eric Roston - Nice     | 68.50.25.xxx | 2008-05-25 23:48:53
I like that the deniers are making lists of themselves. This way the angry future will know who was dragging their feet.
jewelry wholesale - jewelry wholesale     | 222.131.26.xxx | 2008-10-12 22:56:44
wholesale jewelry
jewelry store
fashion jewelry
crystal jewelry
jewelry wholesale
pearl jewelry
wholesale crystal
wholesale pearl
wholesale turquoise jewelry
wholesale pearls
ryllwc - wow gold     | 123.145.166.xxx | 2008-09-09 23:37:18
Professional WoW Power Leveling store,We offer cheap WoW Power Leveling,cheap World of Warcraft WoW Power Leveling,).Free Guide to help you Buy WoW Gold,WoW Power Leveling, and WoW Gold, sessions are really cheap, normally a lot less than the WoW Gold, minimum wage offered in the US because most WoW Gold, of the workers who are wow gold,wow gold,leveling are based in China.WoW Gold, Not only that but they normally are buy WoW Gold able to level faster than the Cheap WoW Gold average player WoW Gold, considering they have workers rotating Cheap WoW Gold shifts along with many many practices in the game. Cheap WoW Gold One of the best part of leveling a brand new character is Cheap WoW Gold that you will have a fresh reputation of the WoW Gold and WoW Gold would be able to name the character as you like. World of warcraft Power Leveling,warcraft Power Leveling,World of warcraft Power Leveling,warcraft Power Leveling,age of conan gold,aoc gold,buy aoc gold,cheap aoc gold,aoc power leveling,age of conan power leveling,aoc power leveling,aoc gold,age of conan gold,age of conan power leveling,guild wars gold,lotro gold,lotro gold,lotr gold,lotr gold,maplestory mesos,maplestory mesos,maplestory mesos,maplestory mesos, maple story mesos,maple story mesos,maple story mesos,maple story mesos,maple story mesos,maplestory mesos,runescape gold,runescape money,aoc gold,age of conan gold,aoc gold, age of conan gold,aoc gold,FFXI Gil,final fantasy gil,oil purifier,rolex replica,replica rolex,chongqingyantai,evening dresses,evening gowns,wedding dresses,bridal gowns,wedding gowns,cocktail dresses,Bridesmaid dresses,prom dresses,formal dresses,girls clothes,baby boy clothes,baby boy clothing,baby girl clothes,baby girl clothing,dog clothes,dog collarsPromotional items,Promotional products,Wedding dresses,Pet supplies,Dog clothes,[url=http://www.lidodo.com]
diezhilian - sdfsd   | 221.221.175.xxx | 2008-09-18 20:45:20
fncv25
Good News, the lowest price for gold coins, the transaction more secure!

Thanks wow goldto the broad wow goldmasses of Warcraftwow gold players have been on my site support, I held gold coins site offers! Launched another delivery of gold coins to buy Dailian cash coupons.wow gold Buy the rest assured, rs goldplaying the happy! Runescape GoldWorld of Warcraft pricesRuneScape Money of all types of business wow power levelingare 9 Dailian Presentation, set for more business!

I createwow power leveling a new Web site World wow power levelingof Warcraft gold coinrolex new service concept,wow power leveling the wow power levelingregion available from stock, creating pure gold coins hand,wow power leveling allows you to buy the rest assured that with the peace of mindwow power leveling. You do not need to worry about enough toWorld of Warcraft gold buy gold coins after the account was afraid of letters, as long as you need, Please be assured of contact us and we guarantee that the first service, safety first

First, the quality of the first.World of Warcraft gold My site is China's largest online game virtual item trading platform, World of Warcraft gold coin, limited Fengqiang! Value buy the whole region-wide service and limited supply! Accounts and other equipment, such as consignment and secured transactions, wow goldTo provide all kinds of virtual goods transactions in the security environment .24-hour customer

Services, a variety of methods of payment,wow gold the transaction security convenient, all servers have goods!
wdw   | 222.210.172.xxx | 2008-09-19 02:10:26
Want to go to tibet tour?You can rely on us!We are offering tibet tours in great discount, The miraculous railway now closely connects mainland China and remote tibet travel, which will speed up economic development tour in tibet. travel to tibet railway will not only bring about tibet trekking a significant change of the mystical view of the outside world to tibet map, but will also create a better cognition of the people by the outside world.tibet tour guide There is a strong belief that Tibet will welcome a better tomorrow thanks to this widely hailed sacred road.Want to go to Tibet tour? You can rely on us!We are offering Tibet tours in great discount,We offer Packages: popular Tibet Tour Packages, Tibet Adventure Travel Packages,Tibet Tours of all kinds.We can also customize your tour to tibet.
Anonymous   | 222.240.139.xxx | 2008-09-23 10:33:50
[size=4]war gold buy war gold warhammer gold[/size]
[size=4]warhammer gold buy warhammer gold war gold[/size]
[size=4]warhammer gold buy warhammer gold war gold[/size]
[size=4]warhammer gold buy warhammer gold war gold[/size]
[size=4]warhammer gold buy warhammer gold war gold[/size]
[size=4]warhammer gold buy warhammer gold war gold[/size]
[size=4]aoc gold buy aoc gold age of conan gold[/size]
[size=4][size=4][siz
e=4][url=http://www.aocsale.com/ ][size=4][size=4]age
of conan gold[/size][/size][/url][/size] buy age of conan gold aoc gold[/size][/size]
[size=4]warhammer gold[/size]










war gold   buy war gold    warhammer goldwarhammer gold   buy warhammer gold    war goldwarhammer gold   buy warhammer gold    war goldwarhammer gold   buy warhammer gold    war goldwarhammer gold   buy warhammer gold    war goldwarhammer gold   buy warhammer gold    war goldaoc gold   buy aoc gold    age of conan goldage of conan gold   buy age of conan gold    aoc goldwarhammer gold
tonysir - wow gold   | 125.77.15.xxx | 2008-10-02 13:40:58
Best wow gold shop here,Buy world of warcraft gold 1st choice.
wow gold   | 122.139.9.xxx | 2008-10-04 04:14:59
To bring all their dreams, open to all efforts to fight the first time. Do not let waiting for the dream, even if this does not fail to regret because we worked hard.
Only in life seem dull and tasteless is empty and flat and tasteless. - Chernyshevsky
wow gold
wow power leveling
wow gold
wow power leveling
wow gold   | 221.221.14.xxx | 2008-10-08 03:13:32
wow gold
When you play a game of wow goldthe day, wow power levelingthe list of friends wow power levelingin the game wow goldwhether wow power levelingthere are always a few names of blacrolexk friends, who have accompanied you to upgrade, to accompany you in Aizelasi travel together, shoulder to shoulder once together Fighting against the forces of evil, has a mysterious caves to explore the unknown, had fallen at BoSS expewow gold wow goldrience with the excitement and fun equipment. Whether the game or reality, the road of life there wow goldare countless friends Friends accompanied, however, perhaps because t hese are the reasons, they temporarily left the game, leaving you alone miss. Peace in the always easy, perhaps you miss the same time thought, maybe these friends have more happiness. wow power leveling But now, when people across the Heianzhimen, found that when the army had already World of Warcraft golddefeated the devil Reunited forces, ready to start a horrendous burning expedition,[url=http
://rs-runescapegold.com/]rs gold[/url] you prepared ? Aizelasi and Karim more quiet Runescape Gold life will soon be broken, alliances and tribal confrontation is no longer meaningful, once the Comade-in-arms, where are you ? Willing to come back to fight RuneScape Moneyside by side, have you desperate to defend the guardian of the world. wow power levelingAizelasi world needs you! In Citie, please write down where you region, the server name, his (ID, career), miss the person (ID, occupation, class), the unforgettable things (not limited number of words), if there are games In Screenshot, please give shots.
dd   | 58.217.234.xxx | 2008-10-10 04:46:17
wedding dresses wedding dresses wedding gowns wedding gowns bridal gowns bridal gowns lace front wigs lace wigs wedding invitations invitations lace wigs wigs
Anonymous   | 82.81.11.xxx | 2008-10-10 07:18:29
rtQBe online casinosrtQBe online casinos forexT6peQ
Write comment
Name:
Website:
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
 
 
Security Image
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved.

 
< Prev   Next >

Hi, We're EnviroWonk

Yeah, OK, we can be the change that we want to see in the world. But unless powerful people in powerful positions want to be that change as well, nothing's going to change.

So now, finally, there's a place where you can go for news and analysis of politics from an environmental perspective.

Weekly Updates

RSS

rss