To almost no one's surprise, the Lieberman-Warner Climate Security Act died unceremoniously this morning. If Congress is to ever implement a comprehensive climate change bill, it will now happen under either President McCain or Obama.

Supporters fell a dozen votes short of making the legislation filibuster-proof. The final tally of 48-36 was specifically on cloture for Senator Barbara Boxer’s (D-CA) 491-page substitute amendment -- the same amendment that Republicans made Senate clerks spend nine hours reading aloud two days ago. The vote forced Majority Leader Harry Reid to withdraw the full bill, and again we wait until next year.

Just to recap, this is a bill that would have capped CO2 emissions from power plants, refineries and factories, with a target of cutting GHG emissions by 71 percent by 2050. Though not without its flaws, it quickly became apparent this week that Republicans had no interest in debating the merits of the legislation, and we ended up with three days of stall tactics and rhetoric about energy prices and "the huge tax increase."

Because you should know, here's a breakdown of how the voting unfolded:

Democrats who joined Republicans in voting to end debate: Byron Dorgan (N.D.), Mary Landrieu (La.), Tim Johnson (S.D.) and Sherrod Brown (Ohio).

Republicans who joined most Democrats to move ahead with the bill: John Warner (Va.), Susan Collins (Maine), Mel Martinez (Fla.), Elizabeth Dole (N.C.), John Sununu (N.H.), olympia Snowe (Maine) and Gordon Smith (Ore.).

Did not vote: Robert Byrd (D-W.Va.), Ted Kennedy (D-Mass.), Hillary Clinton (D-N.Y.), Kent Conrad (D-N.D.), Joe Biden (D-Del.), Norm Coleman (R-Minn.), Larry Craig (R-Idaho), John Cornyn (R-Tex.), Jim DeMint (R-S.C.), Judd Gregg (R-N.H.), Lindey Graham (R-S.C.), Arlen Specter (R-Pa.), Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) and Ted Stevens (R-Alaska).

We should note that Biden, Clinton, Coleman, Kennedy, McCain, and Obama submitted statements indicating they would have voted for cloture, but that still would have left the majority six votes short of preventing a filibuster.

Comments (6)

Subscribe to this comment's feed

wholesale jewelry
written by wholesale jewelry, September 15, 2008

http://www.aypearl.net
http://www.aypearl.net
http://www.aypearl.net
http://www.aypearl.net
http://www.aypearl.net
http://www.aypearl.net/Html/turquoise_Jewelry/
http://www.aypearl.net/Html/Gemstone_Jewelry/
http://www.aypearl.net/Html/Coral_Jewelry/
http://www.aypearl.net/Html/Shell_Jewelry/

handmade jewelry
written by handmade jewelry, September 15, 2008

http://www.bjbead.com
http://www.bjbead.com
http://www.bjbead.com
http://www.bjbead.com
http://www.bjbead.com/pearl-jewelry/
http://www.bjbead.com/turquoise-jewelry/
http://www.bjbead.com/coral-jewelry/
http://www.bjbead.com/shell-jewelry/
http://www.bjbead.com
http://www.bjbead.com/gemstone-jewelry/

...
written by vov, September 23, 2008

...
written by a guest, October 07, 2008

Want to go to http://www.u-waytours.com? You can rely on us! We are expert in http://www.u-waytours.com. based in Tibet 15 years experience, 600 private groups operated! So join us for your wondrous http://www.u-waytours.com! Are you interested in mysterious Lhasa http://www.u-waytours.com? Why not take our Lhasa http://www.u-waytours.com/tibet_11.htm? You can appreciate the holiness of Lhasa .http://www.u-waytours.com/tibet_tour.htm with our well-connected itinerary and leave a memorable recollection over life. These are China Lhasa http://www.u-waytours.com/tibet_thangka.htm packages with personal local http://www.u-waytours.com/join_in_group.htm, and private vehicle with driver + hotels + entrance fees and meals as listed for your party based on minimum 2 travelers. For single person, please email us for new quotations. http://www.u-waytours.com/tibet_buddhist.htm For any questions, please feel free to contact our customer team with our prompt and personalized travel services.

...
written by dd, October 10, 2008

http://www.vponsale.com/ wedding dresses http://www.vponsale.com/ wedding gowns http://www.vponsale.com/ bridal gowns http://www.rpgshow.com/ lace wigs http://www.vponsale.com/invitations/ invitations http://www.rpgshow.com/lace-wigs-c-9.html wigs

yiwu
written by yiwu agent, December 23, 2008

My name is Anne, from East Africa. I have imported 3 containers (40 HQ) discount wholesale shoes from leading China wholesaler: http://www.amandaiec.com. Top quality, lowest China wholesale price. Only US$ 2.99/pair.